Child custody issues arise when parents separate or divorce. In California, the courts encourage shared custody. The court rulings on custody ensure the child has a meaningful relationship with both parents. However, there are circumstances when parental conflict results in a restraining order. The presence of a restraining order can impact child custody and visitation arrangements.
The court issues restraining orders due to allegations of harassment, abuse, or violence. A restraining order restricts one parent from having contact with the other parent. Sharing child custody while a restraining order is in place is complex. When awarding custody under these circumstances, family courts assess each situation individually.
A judge may consider the nature of the restraining order, the relationship between the parents, and any history of abuse. If you are in the middle of a child custody battle with a restraining order in place, you will need the guidance of a skilled restraining order attorney.
Understanding Shared Custody with a Restraining Order
When parents separate or divorce, child custody becomes a critical issue. Custody arrangements determine where the child will live. Additionally, it sets forth the parent's involvement in making decisions about the child's life. The courts encourage maintaining a relationship with both parents, assuming they provide a stable environment. However, this presumption may not apply in situations with safety concerns.
Shared custody becomes far more complicated when a restraining order is in place. A restraining order is a legal order issued by a court to protect an individual from harassment, abuse, or threats. A restraining order raises significant concerns about the safety of the children.
When a restraining order is in place, the court will consider it when determining shared custody arrangements. Courts must balance protecting all involved with fostering healthy relationships between parents and children.
Factors Considered by the Court When Awarding Shared Child Custody
In cases where one parent has a restraining order against the other, the court may consider several factors to determine the appropriateness of shared custody. They include:
Physical Safety of the Child
If there are allegations of physical abuse or a history of violence, the court is likely to limit the abusive parent’s access to the child. If a parent poses a physical threat to a child, the court may order supervised visitation or deny custody altogether.
Sometimes, the restraining order may include restrictions on the abusive parent’s ability to be around the child. In cases where the child is harmed, the restraining order can consist of a no-contact order.
The Child’s Emotional and Psychological Safety
Even in the absence of physical violence, emotional abuse or coercion can pose risks to a child’s well-being. The court ensures the psychological and emotional well-being of the child by ordering supervised visitation. In the presence of the following factors, the court can determine that shared custody is inappropriate:
- Evidence of manipulation
- Verbal abuse,
- Emotional harm.
- Impact of Restraining Orders on Shared Custody
Impact of a Restraining Order on Shared Custody
If there is a history of abuse, the court is less likely to order shared custody. Instead, a judge can impose supervised visitation or other restrictions. When making custody decisions, the court prioritizes the child's best interests. Allowing contact with both parents after a separation or divorce is ideal for the child.
However, the shared custody becomes complicated when there is a restraining order. Parents can seek restraining orders against each other for abuse, harassment, or violence. Navigating shared custody with a restraining order has the following effects:
Influence on Co-parenting Communication
Effective co-parenting communication is crucial in shared custody situations. However, the issuance of a restraining order often disrupts this dynamic. The court may prohibit the restrained parent from directly communicating with the other parent. Such an order can make discussing essential child well-being decisions challenging.
The court mitigates the issue by establishing alternative means of communication. They include third-party intermediaries or written correspondence. The limitation can reduce the ability of the parents to work together, leading to increased tension and conflict.
Psychological Impact on the Child
The effects of a restraining order on a child are not only logistical but also emotional and psychological. Children may feel caught in parental conflict when one parent does not have physical or unsupervised contact. The change can cause confusion, anxiety, or feelings of guilt. The psychological impact of a restraining order is higher for children who understand its implications.
Children who are subject to custody arrangements that restrict time with one parent may experience abandonment. This can affect their emotional development and relationship with both parents.
Long-Term Custody Considerations
Sometimes, a restraining order can lead to long-term changes in the custody arrangement. If a parent has a history of abusive behavior or poses a continued risk to the child, the court may terminate their custody rights. Loss of custody for one parent can result in a permanent shift from shared custody to sole custody.
Under these circumstances, the restrained parent will receive supervised visitation or no contact. The court makes long-term custody decisions considering the child’s best interests. Therefore, a restraining order indicates a need to reevaluate the safety and stability of shared custody.
Impact of Domestic Violence Restraining Orders on Child Custody Decisions in California
Domestic violence restraining orders are common in California. The courts issue these orders to protect the victims of domestic violence and abuse. Domestic violence is a significant factor in child custody cases. California law recognizes the detrimental effects of domestic violence on children.
Therefore, the judge takes these incidents into account when making custody decisions. Some of the effects of domestic violence restraining orders on custody and visitation include:
Presumption Against Custody to the Abusive Parent
California law presumes that a parent with a domestic violence restraining order should not be granted custody, but this presumption can be challenged with sufficient evidence. If a parent is issued a domestic violence restraining order, the court can deny them custody. The denial is based on the assumption that their interaction with the child is not in the child's best interest.
Sometimes, the abusive parent may attempt to rebut this presumption. This is by presenting evidence that it is safe for the child to have custody or visitation. While the court will consider the evidence, the presumption remains.
Protecting Children from Exposure to Domestic Violence
The court’s priority is to protect the child from exposure to violence or harm. Even if the abusive parent has not harmed the child, exposure to domestic violence can impact the child’s well-being. Therefore, the court may limit or deny custody to the abusive parent to prevent the child from further exposure to harm.
Limited Parental Rights for Domestic Violence
The court recognizes that both parents have the right to be involved in the child’s life. However, the primary concern is the child’s safety. A domestic violence restraining order does not strip the parent of their parental rights. However, it can significantly impact their custody and visitation privileges.
Shared Custody Arrangements with a Restraining Order
Shared custody is still possible in cases where one parent has a restraining order against the other. Under these circumstances, the court may establish certain conditions to ensure the safety of the child and the protected parent. These conditions could include:
Supervised Visitation
Supervised visitation is a typical child custody arrangement when a restraining order is in place. In this case, the court may allow the abusive parent to visit with the child. However, the visitation is under the supervision of a neutral third party. Supervised visitation ensures the child’s protection. Additionally, it allows the parent to have some relationship with the child.
The supervisor ensures that the visitation is safe and that the child is not exposed to harm. Supervised visitation may take place in a designated facility or a designated area. The court schedules these visits to ensure compliance with the restraining order and visitation terms.
Safe Exchange Locations
Restraining orders protect a person from abuse, harassment, or violence from the restrained individual. A common term of the restraining order is for the restrained person to avoid contact with the protected individual. Sometimes, a parent may threaten the other parent but not their child.
Under these circumstances, the court may order that the child exchanges occur at a neutral location. It minimizes the chance of conflict between the parents and ensures the child’s safety.
Gradual Reintroduction
The court may order a gradual reintroduction of visitation or custody. Such an arrangement is suitable if shared custody is desired, but there is a concern about the abusive parent’s behavior. Gradual reintroduction can start with supervised visitation and transition to unsupervised visitation. The court can eventually allow joint custody if the restrained parent commits to change. Additionally, the child’s safety remains assured.
Therapeutic Intervention
A shared custody arrangement may come as a modification from sole custody. The court can award sole custody to one parent if the other parent threatens the child's safety. However, with the change of circumstances, the restrained parent can seek a modification of the custody order.
The court may order that the abusive parent undergo therapy or anger management courses. These interventions are part of a larger plan to reunify the family safely and healthily. The court can deny the shared custody request if the restrained parent fails to complete the counseling.
Strict Conditions for Custody and Visitation
If the court allows shared custody with a restraining order, the judge may impose strict conditions for the restrained parent. They include adhering to a court-ordered safety plan and complying with counseling. Additionally, the court may order the abusive parent not to engage in any further acts of violence or harassment.
Modifying a Custody or Visitation Order After a Restraining Order
If you have shared child custody, the order may need modification if one parent is issued a restraining order. Modifying custody arrangements post-restraining order is a complex process. However, it is possible depending on the specific circumstances.
Restraining orders address issues of safety and protection, especially in domestic violence situations. You can request a custody order modification if the restraining order impacts the child's best interests.
A parent who wishes to change custody arrangements due to the presence of a restraining order must petition the court for a modification. The court will consider several factors before modifying the custody order:
-
The best interest of the child.
The child's best interests are a critical factor during shared custody. The court will assess how the restraining order will affect the child's safety. Additionally, the judge can factor in how the custody modification will impact the child. -
Reason for the restraining order
. The court can issue a restraining order for different safety concerns. If the restraining order is related to domestic violence or child abuse, the court may limit or restrict custody and visitation. DVROs are issued when the restrained person threatens the safety of the child or the other parent. -
Change in circumstances
. After a divorce or separation, the court favors joint custody. The arrangement allows the child to maintain a relationship with both parents. However, issuing a restraining order indicates a change in circumstances that can warrant a modification.
Find a Competent Restraining Order Attorney Near Me
The California court system aims to protect children's safety and well-being. However, it recognizes the legal rights of parents to access and spend time with their children. Therefore, parents can share custody of the child even when a restraining order exists. If a restraining order exists, the court may order supervised visitation to ensure the child's safety.
Sometimes, the parent subject to the restraining order may only interact with the child in a protected environment. The parent seeking custody or visitation rights may need to provide evidence of their ability to care for the child in a safe environment.
Child custody or visitation arrangements can undergo modifications depending on the circumstances. While you navigate your custody and restraining order issues in California, you will benefit from the expert legal insight we offer at Goldman Flores Restraining Order Law Firm. Call us today at 213-341-4087 to discuss your case.
